At Benny's Pizza, we serve more than just pizza. Dive into a menu packed with hearty Italian favorites, fresh salads, crispy sides, and classic sandwiches. Our pizza options feature generous toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms on a perfectly baked crust. Craving something different? Try our Italian beef, lasagna, or a flavorful chicken sandwich. We cater to all cravings with quick bites, late-night specials, and family-sized meals. Located at 1102 W Lincoln Ave in Milwaukee, our welcoming spot is perfect for lunch, dinner, or a late-night snack. Plus, we deliver to South 27th Street, making comfort food just a call away.
Benny's offers affordability without sacrificing quality, with prices below $15 for many dishes. Whether dine-in, takeout, or delivery, Benny’s makes it easy to enjoy authentic, satisfying food anytime.
Saintly pizza or spicy wings, relish every bite knowing Benny’s commits to fresh ingredients and friendly service. Join the Milwaukee community that’s been enjoying our generous portions and cozy vibe since 2013. Our casual yet trendy atmosphere ensures a perfect place for solo dinners or groups celebrating together. Nice parking options and wheelchair accessibility make dining convenient for everyone.
About Benny's Pizza Food and Specialties
Benny’s Pizza specializes in Italian-American comfort food with a Milwaukee twist. Their pizza, a community favorite, boasts crispy crusts, rich toppings, and flavorful sauces. Locals love their pepperoni and sausage offerings, but Benny's also excels in hearty sandwiches like their famous Italian beef and chicken sandwiches, packed with generous portions of seasoned meat and fresh bread.
Beyond pizza, you’ll find an extensive selection of sides, including onion rings, cheese sticks, and garlic bread—perfect complements to any meal. The menu features classic dishes like lasagna, spaghetti, and shrimp dinners, all prepared with care and crafted for consistent quality.
Benny's also caters to family and group dining, with options suitable for kids, such as their kids’ menu, and amenities like high chairs. Their culinary focus combines tradition with a modern, casual vibe, making each visit a satisfying experience that keeps the community coming back year after year.
Discover Benny's Pizza Menu
Benny's Pizza, located at 1102 W Lincoln Ave in Milwaukee, offers a diverse menu centered on Italian comfort foods and classic American favorites. Whether you're craving a cheesy slice of pizza or a hearty Italian beef sandwich, Benny's delivers flavorful options made with fresh ingredients. Their menu features a variety of appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and hearty entrees, perfect for lunch or dinner. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery—especially to south 27th Street—they accommodate busy schedules and casual gatherings.
Enjoy their signature offerings like pepperoni pizza, crispy chicken sandwiches, and flavorful wings.
Small plates like mozzarella sticks and onion rings satisfy snack cravings. The menu also includes larger meals such as lasagna, shrimp dinners, and veal parmigiana. Benny’s is popular for its generous portions, friendly service, and reasonable prices, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether dining solo or with a group, Benny’s creates an inviting environment to enjoy classic comfort food at any time of day.
At Benny's Pizza, our mission is to serve authentic, high-quality comfort food that builds community. We focus on delivering freshly made dishes with a focus on flavor and affordability. Our specialties include hand-tossed pizzas with classic toppings like pepperoni and mushrooms, alongside hearty sandwiches like Italian beef and chicken sandwich. We envision being more than a restaurant; we aim to be a Milwaukee gathering place where everyone feels at home. Protecting our community’s health is paramount, and we adhere strictly to local health regulations. Our goal is to keep our community connected through food, warmth, and shared moments—making Benny’s a cornerstone of Milwaukee’s vibrant local scene.